RECURRENCE OF CITED OSHA STANDARDS U.S. Manufacturing Plants, 2015-2022 139,777 first citations followed at 28,339 U.S. manufacturing plants · 13 October 2026 RESEARCH REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS Section 01 OVERVIEW 3 Summary 5 Section 02 KEY FINDINGS 6 Fewer than 1 in 8 gets a second look 8 Nearly 1 in 18 is cited again 9 Machine guarding comes back most 10 Most return visits are partial 11 Similar across manufacturing 12 Section 03 NUANCES & SCOPE 13 Why the second inspection matters 14 What we measured 15 How this compares with earlier research 16 Section 04 IN PRACTICE 17 What this means on a shop floor 18 Three checks after every citation 19 Section 05 RIGOR & METHOD 20 How we checked this 21 Alternative definitions 22 Method 23 Limitations 24 Appendix DATA & SOURCES 25 Every ranked rule 25 About this research · Sources 28 OVERVIEW KEY FINDINGS NUANCES & SCOPE IN PRACTICE RIGOR & METHOD APPENDIX & SOURCES RECURRENCE OF CITED OSHA STANDARDS · SDS MANAGER 2026 2 Section 01 OVERVIEW OVERVIEW KEY FINDINGS NUANCES & SCOPE IN PRACTICE RIGOR & METHOD APPENDIX & SOURCES RECURRENCE OF CITED OSHA STANDARDS · SDS MANAGER 2026 3 SECTION 01 · OVERVIEW What happens after an OSHA citation closes? The case file says the hazard was fixed. Whether it stayed fixed is something almost nobody checks. We followed nearly 140,000 citations to see what OSHA found when it came back. 139,777 first citations followed at 28,339 U.S. manufacturing plants, cases closed 2015-2022 12.0% got a qualifying OSHA return visit within about three years: fewer than 1 in 8 5.4% of those were cited again for the identical rule: nearly 1 in 18 OVERVIEW KEY FINDINGS NUANCES & SCOPE IN PRACTICE RIGOR & METHOD APPENDIX & SOURCES RECURRENCE OF CITED OSHA STANDARDS · SDS MANAGER 2026 4 OVERVIEW SUMMARY When OSHA cites a plant, the case closes once the employer certifies the fix. We wanted to know what happens after that, so we followed 139,777 first citations at 28,339 manufacturing plants under federal OSHA. In most cases the public record goes quiet. Only 16,831 citations (12.0%) were followed by a qualifying OSHA visit within about three years. For the remaining 122,946, there is no way to tell from OSHA's records whether the hazard stayed fixed. When OSHA did come back, 916 of 16,831 citations (5.4%) were cited again for the identical paragraph (95% range 5.0% to 6.0%). Some rules return far more often than others. 1910.212(a)(1) machine guarding came back in 23.3% of cases, the highest of the 106 rules with enough data to rank. OSHA applied its own Repeat label far less often, to 361 of these pairs. And 90.4% of return visits were partial inspections, which may not have looked at the original hazard at all. For a safety manager, the upshot is that OSHA is unlikely to re-check a citation on your behalf. Machine guarding and lockout/tagout, the rules that come back most often, are sensible places to start checking yourself. These figures describe OSHA's records for the plants it chose to inspect. They do not measure how safe any individual plant is. 5.4% of followed citations cited again for the same rule 12.0% of citations got a qualifying return visit 23.3% for 1910.212(a)(1), the top rule 139,777 first citations followed, 2015-2022 OVERVIEW KEY FINDINGS NUANCES & SCOPE IN PRACTICE RIGOR & METHOD APPENDIX & SOURCES RECURRENCE OF CITED OSHA STANDARDS · SDS MANAGER 2026 5
100%
The Second Look: Why Most OSHA Citations Are Never Rechecked — cover

That’s the end of the preview

Download the PDF to read the full report.

Report · Free PDF

The Second Look: Why Most OSHA Citations Are Never Rechecked

3 downloads

28 pages · PDF

Free research report (PDF). We followed 139,777 OSHA citations at 28,339 U.S. manufacturing plants to see how often OSHA comes back and which rules get cited again.

What's inside

  • Five key findings, from whether OSHA returns at all to how results differ by manufacturing sector
  • The share of citations that got a qualifying OSHA return visit within about three years
  • How often the same exact paragraph was cited again, compared with OSHA's own Repeat label
  • A ranking of 106 OSHA standards by how often they come back, led by machine guarding and lockout/tagout
  • Why most return visits are partial inspections that may never look at the original hazard
  • Three checks to run after every OSHA citation
  • Full method, sensitivity checks, limitations and sources

Who it's for

  • Safety directors who oversee OSHA compliance across several plants
  • Site safety managers who close out citations and keep the abatement evidence
  • Plant, facilities and operations managers responsible for machine guarding, lockout/tagout and equipment changes
  • EHS analysts and consultants who use OSHA enforcement data

How an OSHA citation closes

When OSHA cites a workplace, the employer has to correct each hazard by the abatement date. For most citations, the employer then certifies the correction in writing, and for many it also sends evidence such as photos, invoices or training records. Once OSHA accepts that, the case closes.

From then on, OSHA's public record says nothing about the hazard unless OSHA comes back. The case file shows a fix was certified. It doesn't show whether the fix still holds a year later.

How often does OSHA come back?

Not often. Of the 139,777 first citations in our study, only 16,831 (12.0%) were followed by a qualifying OSHA return visit within about three years. The typical gap was 522 days. For the other 122,946 citations, OSHA's records can't tell you whether the hazard stayed fixed.

When OSHA did return, it usually wasn't a full inspection. 90.4% of return visits were partial in scope, and 82.2% were triggered by a complaint or referral. A complaint about a forklift won't re-examine a machine guard.

How often is the same rule cited again?

At the first qualifying return visit, 916 of the 16,831 followed citations (5.4%) were cited again for the identical paragraph, nearly 1 in 18. When we counted only complete-scope return visits, the share rose to 7.4%.

Since partial visits may not look at the original hazard, treat these numbers as a floor, not an estimate of how often hazards really come back.

OSHA repeat violations vs. the same rule cited again

An OSHA repeat violation is a formal classification. OSHA uses it when an employer was previously cited for the same or a substantially similar condition and the earlier citation became a final order. Repeat violations carry OSHA's highest penalty range, so a recurring hazard can cost far more the second time.

In our data, OSHA applied the Repeat label to 361 citations. In the same group, 916 were cited again for the identical paragraph. The formal label tells a smaller story than the citation data.

Which OSHA standards come back most?

Of 106 OSHA standards with enough data to rank, machine guarding and lockout/tagout lead the list:

  • 1910.212(a)(1) machine guarding: 23.3% cited again
  • 1910.147(d) lockout/tagout application of control: 21.1%
  • 1910.212(a)(3)(ii) point-of-operation guarding: 14.8%
  • 1910.147(d)(4)(i) lockout/tagout devices affixed: 11.3%
  • 1910.134(e)(1) respirator medical evaluation: 11.2%

These controls have to hold up every shift. Guards come off for maintenance and don't go back on, and lockout steps get skipped when production is under pressure or a new crew takes over.

The results were similar across manufacturing sectors, ranging from 4.8% to 5.9%. Recurrence comes down to which rules and controls are involved, not which industry.

Three checks after every OSHA citation

The report includes a checklist page. Each check takes under an hour:

  1. Re-verify the cited condition. A few months after the case closes, go back to the machine or task named in the citation and check the exact paragraph. If it fails, treat it as a new finding.
  2. Check the same rule elsewhere. Look at other lines, shifts and buildings with the same equipment or task, and extend the corrective action there.
  3. Keep the evidence with the case. File photos, work orders and training records with the citation. A certified fix without evidence can't be shown to a later inspector.

About the data

The study uses U.S. Department of Labor OSHA inspection and violation records for federal OSHA manufacturing plants (NAICS 31–33), cases closed 2015–2022. It describes OSHA's records for the plants OSHA chose to inspect. It doesn't measure how safe any individual plant is.

Download the free report to see the full ranking of OSHA standards and the three-check worksheet. If your site has been cited, the 20-Minute Safety Walk checklist is a practical way to keep re-checking the floor.

Arysha Alif Khan

Manager- Product Compliance

Arysha Alif Khan is an EHS and chemical safety specialist with a background in biochemistry, biotechnology, and public health. She works closely with the product and regulatory teams to turn complex chemical regulations, SDS requirements, and workplace safety standards into clear, practical guidance for people.